How Sensitive is climate to CO2?

We are continuing to emit vast amounts of CO2 into our Atmosphere. We know that CO2 is a greenhouse gas, so the question is to wonder just what all this CO2 is going to do to our climate.

There exists a range. A landmark report from 1979 concluded that it probably lies between 1.5‐4.5°C per doubling of atmospheric carbon dioxide. That is still quite a wide margin. Is it possible multiple decades later to narrow that?

Yes it is, a major new study has done just that.

Tip: this is a rather important climate science paper.

Study: An assessment of Earth’s climate sensitivity using multiple lines of evidence

Published July 22, 2020 within Reviews of Geophysics, this new international assessment of the Earth’s climate sensitivity has greatly improved our understanding of how much the world will eventually warm if the carbon dioxide in the atmosphere is maintained at double the level of pre-industrial times.

  • The journal link in the title has a paywall, but you can gain access to a pdf of the full paper here.

For context, a doubling is determined as follows. Just before the industrial revolution the CO2 within our atmosphere was 278 parts of CO₂ per million. Right now, it is 413.93ppm and so if we sustain our current rates then we will reach a doubling of the 278 by roughly 2080.

How did the researchers determine how sensitive the climate will be in this new paper?

Putting it simplistically, they approached the question by looking at three distinct lines of evidence …

  1. Historical measurements that date back to the 1850s: By looking over this time span what do the longer term trends reveal?
  2. Paleoclimate records: For example, 4 million years ago the CO2 levels were similar to today’s level, so what did that do then?
  3. Climate models: These take into account the deep complexity and all the feedbacks and interactions within our climate system, what are these telling us?

What is the new conclusion?

It has been generally accepted that the range was 1.5‐4.5°C increase per doubling of CO2. In its 5th Assessment Report, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) quoted these values as the “likely range.

  • Translation: that’s a 66% probability that it is within that range, and 33% that it might be higher or lower.

This new paper now changes that.

The “likely range” has narrowed to, at most, 2.3°C to 4.5°C

WCRP = World Climate Research Programme, the folks who organised the new international study


The lower end of the previous range is gone.

They find that a large volume of consistent evidence now points to a more confident view of a climate sensitivity near the middle or upper part of this range. In particular, it now appears extremely unlikely that the climate sensitivity could be low enough to avoid substantial climate change (well in excess of 2°C warming) under a high‐emissions future scenario.

They also were unable to rule out that the sensitivity could be above 4.5°C per doubling of carbon dioxide levels, although this is not likely.

Bottom Line: There is much greater certainty that, if left unchecked, global warming would be high enough to bring very severe impacts and risks worldwide.

I should add that we can still make a difference by what we choose to do about emissions. There is still a degree of uncertainty here regarding what will actually happen. We really really should not actually do the experiment for real, actually doubling the CO2, to see what then happens.

CO2 and Climate Sensitivity – tweets

Leave a ReplyCancel reply

Exit mobile version